feat & Co
Help Center

Collecting societies (CMO/PRO)Collecting societiesPRS for MusicASCAPBMI

My song registration has a conflict or duplicate claim

Quick answer

A registration conflict (or counterclaim) happens when registrations of the same song disagree: shares add up to more than 100 percent, a writer is missing, or someone else claims the song. Societies usually hold the disputed money until the parties agree. Compare the registrations, contact the other party with your evidence (split sheet, session files, contracts), agree corrected shares, and have both sides send the correction to the society. If you cannot agree, a lawyer may be needed.

Who can fix it
You, Your co-writers, Your publisher, Your society
Typical time
Weeks to months, depending on how quickly everyone agrees

What's going on

Your society has found registrations of the same song that do not agree. Common causes:

  • Over-claim: co-writers registered different shares, so the total is more than 100 percent.
  • Missing or extra writer: one registration leaves someone out or adds a person who did not write.
  • Publisher overlap: two publishers or administrators claim the same writer share, often after a deal ended.
  • Duplicate work: the same song registered twice under different titles or spellings (for example Arabic and transliterated titles).
  • Wrong match: a different song with the same title has been linked to your recording.
  • Unauthorised claim: someone has registered your song as theirs.

While a conflict is open, societies usually hold the disputed share and pay it once it is resolved.

How to fix it

  1. Get the details from your society's member portal or member services: which work, which party and which shares are in conflict.
  2. Gather your evidence: split sheet, co-writing agreement, publishing contracts, session files, dated demos, messages agreeing splits. See what is a split sheet.
  3. Contact the other party politely and in writing. Many conflicts are honest mistakes, such as a co-writer entering 50 percent instead of 33.33 percent.
  4. Agree the corrected shares and put them in writing, signed by everyone affected.
  5. Correct the registrations. Edit the works you registered. At ASCAP you can only edit works you registered; for others, send a Member Service Inquiry about the work record. If a correction removes or reduces someone's share, societies may require signed confirmation from that person.
  6. Tell your publisher or administrator if you have one: they handle conflicts with other publishers and societies.
  7. Check the result after the next registration cycle and confirm held money is released.

If that doesn't work

  • The other party will not reply or agree: ask your society how it handles unresolved disputes and how long it holds money. Rules differ by society.
  • Payments look wrong after the fix: file a payment query or complaint. GEMA, for example, has a Reklamation service in its online portal, with deadlines per distribution.
  • Someone is deliberately claiming your song: keep all evidence and speak to a music lawyer. This is general information, not legal advice.

How to prevent it

  • Sign a split sheet on the day of the session.
  • Let one person register the song at each society and share the confirmation with everyone.
  • Use the same title spelling everywhere and list alternative titles.
  • Tell your society when a publishing deal ends.

See also How to register a song with your collecting society.

Official help for this problem

Direct links to the platform or society pages that handle this case.

Not able to do it?

Send us a ticket and we'll help you work it out.

Have these ready:

  • Song title, ISWC or society work ID
  • All writers and publishers with the shares you believe are correct
  • The conflicting party and the shares they claimed
  • Your evidence: split sheet, contracts, session files
  • Screenshots of the conflict notice from your society
Send us a ticket →

Questions people also ask

Do I lose the money while a song is in conflict?

Usually not straight away. Societies generally hold the disputed share and pay it once the parties agree, but holding periods and rules differ, so act quickly.

What evidence helps resolve a conflict?

A signed split sheet or co-writing agreement is strongest. Session files, dated demos and messages agreeing the splits also help.

Can the society decide who is right?

Societies generally do not judge ownership disputes. They hold money until the parties agree or a court or agreement settles it.

Was this guide helpful?

Last checked against official sources on 28 October 2026. General information, not legal or financial advice. Platforms change their tools often: if a step looks different, tell us.

Related guides